Japanese learning (A5 S24): Benefactive expressions, I did something for someone, and the subject is “I”; Watashi wa [Someone] ni [Verb Clause]+te Agemashita.

Now, we will learn the third benefactive expression, “[V-te] Agemashita.” This time in the section 24, all the sentences are of past/perfect tense. Let us review three types of benefactive expression as shown below;

<V-te Morau> : Watashi wa [Someone] ni [V-te] Moraimashita. — A3

<V-te Kureru> : [Someone] wa [#1]* [V-te] Kuremashita. —A4

<V-te Ageru> : Watashi wa [#2]** [V-te] Agemashita. — A5

* “Watashi” and a proper particle may be put into [#1]. As was shown in yesterday’s post;

– Satou-san wa Watashi ni Shukudai no Kotae o Misete Kuremashita.

– Suzuki-san wa Watashi o Kyouto e Tsurete Itte Kuremashita.

– Takahashi-san wa Watashi no Hikkoshi o Tetsudatte Kuremashita.

the particle for “Watashi” is “ni”, “o”, or “no” depending on the verb used in the sentence.

** [Someone] and a proper particle may be put into [#2]. This is what we are learning today.

– Watashi wa Satou-san ni DVD o Kashite Agemashita. (I lent a DVD to Sato-san.)

– Watashi wa Satou-san o Byouin ni Tsurete Itte Agemashita. (I took Sato-san to a hospital.)

– Watashi wa Satou-san no Chuugokugo o Naoshite Agemashita. (I corrected Sato-san’s Chinese.)

At the end of the section 24, here are some quizzes.

(1) Watashi wa Satou-san ni Kanji o Oshiete Moraimashita.

(2) Suzuki-san wa Watashi o Eki e Tsurete Itte Kuremashita.

(3) Watashi wa Takahashi-san no Hikkoshi o Tetsudatte Agemashita.

Q1: I helped someone, and the subject of the sentence is “I”. Which of (1)-(3) is this?

Q2: Someone helped me, and the subject is someone. Which of (1)-(3) is this?

Q3: Someone helped me, but the subject is “I”. Which of (1)-(3) is this?

This post was written with reference to the exercise A4 on Section24 of “Minna no Nihongo (2nd Edition)” published by “3A Corporation”

Japanese learning (A4 S24): Benefactive expressions, someone did something for me, and the subject is that person; [Someone] wa [Verb Clause]+te Kuremashita.

We have already learned another type of benefactive expression that uses “Morau/Moraimasu” for the predicate verb;

1. Watashi wa [Someone] ni [Verb Clause]+te Moraimashita.

Although the sentence construction of today is as follows;

2. [Someone] wa [Verb Clause]+te Kuremashita.

In order to compare 1 and 2, let us put the word “Watashi” into the sentence 2. Usually “Watashi” is followed by the particle “ni”

3. [Someone] wa Watashi ni [Verb Clause]+te Kuremashita.

In the followings, the example sentences are shown in the order of [V-te]Moraimashita (1.) first, and then [V-te]Kuremashita(3.).

4-1 Watashi wa Satou-san ni Shukudai no Kotae o Misete Moraimashita.

(I was shown the answers of homework by Sato-san.)

4-2 Satou-san wa Watashi ni Shukudai no Kotae o Misete Kuremashita.

(Sato-san showed me the answers of homework.)

4-1 is a sentence of “[V-te]Moraimashita”, and 4-2 is of “[V-te]Kuremashita”. When changing from 4-1 to 4-2, the subject “Watashi” turns to be “Satou-san”. When it comes to particles, “[person]ni [object]o” doesn’t change (although who the [person] is changes).

5-1 Watashi wa Suzuki-san ni Kyouto e Tsurete Itte Moraimashita.

(I was taken to Kyoto by Suzuki-san.)

5-2 Suzuki-san wa Watashi o Kyouto e Tsurete Itte Kuremashita.

(Suzuki-san took me to Kyoto.)

Different from 4-1, “[person]ni [object]o” is not used from the first (5-1), it’s “[person]ni [destination]e”. Interestingly enough, “[person]ni” doesn’t appear in 5-2, instead, “[person]o (=Watashi o)” is in 5-2. This is because the compound verb “Tsurete-iku/Tsurete-ikimasu” is a transitive verb which strongly needs the object with the particle “o”.

6-1 Watashi wa Takahashi-san ni Hikkoshi o Tetsudatte Moraimashita.

(I was helped for my moving by Takahashi-san.)

6-2 Takahashi-san wa Watashi no Hikkoshi o Tetsudatte Kuremashita.

(Takahashi-san helped me move.)

The combination of particles “[person]ni [object]o” in 6-1 cannot be retained in 6-2. “Watashi ni Hikkoshi o Tetsudau” is wrong, “Watashi no Hikkoshi o Tetsudau” is right.

Most of the case, the combination of particles “[person]ni [object]o” is applicable, but in some cases, applying “[person]ni [object]o” could end up incorrect expression.

This post was written with reference to the exercise A4 on Section24 of “Minna no Nihongo (2nd Edition)” published by “3A Corporation”

Japanese learning (A3 S24): Benefactive expressions, someone did something for me, the subject is not that person but “I”; Watashi wa [Someone] ni [Verb Clause]+te Moraimashita.

We have already learned three giving/receiving verbs; Ageru, Morau, and Kureru. So far the sentence constructions using these verbs are about giving and receiving an object.

1. [ I ]wa [ Someone ]ni [ Object ]o Agemasu.  — I will be a giver

2. [ I ]wa [ Someone ]ni [ Object ]o Moraimashita. — I was a receiver

3. [ Someone ]wa [ I ]ni [ Object ]o Kuremashita. — I was a receiver, but the subject is the giver

It’s apart from the point, but did you notice that the sentence 1 is in future tense, 2 and 3 are in past tense? In the sentence 1, action “giving” will be done by me. Therefore, “I” can say what I will do in the future as an expression of will. But in the sentence 2 and 3, “giving” will be done by someone other than “I”. You can’t be perfectly sure what other people will do in the future, even if you are expecting that someone will give you something. In order to make the examples good to be practical, those 2 and 3 are using past tense. If someone gave you something in the past, it’s a sure thing so that you can express other people’s action that is “gave me”.

Anyway, the sentences 1 to 3 are expressing doing a favor by giving an object. Then, how can we express doing a favor by doing an action? The exercises A3, A4, and A5 introduce the sentence constructions that express doing a favor by doing an action. Today, we are learning one of the three, “[V-te]+Morau” as shown below;

– Watashi wa Satou-san ni Shukudai no Kotae o Misete Moraimashita.

(I was shown the answers of homework by Sato-san.)

– Watashi wa Suzuki-san ni Kyouto e Tsurete Itte Moraimashita.

(I was taken to Kyoto by Suzuki-san.)

– Watashi wa Takahashi-san ni Hikkoshi o Tetsudatte Moraimashita.

(I was helped for my moving by Takahashi-san.)

This post was written with reference to the exercise A3 on Section24 of “Minna no Nihongo (2nd Edition)” published by “3A Corporation”